sweetist

Scroll to Info & Navigation

Award-Winning Treats

We get it. It could be a little overwhelming when you first look at Sweetist with all the mouthwatering desserts just screaming "EAT ME, EAT ME!" at you.

So let's find a good starting point. How about you try these award-winning desserts first? We clearly love them, and now you can get a second opinion from a reputable source as well!

Levain_Bakery_Cover_Photo (1)

Let's start off with the definite crowd pleaser - Levain's chocolate chip cookies. They were named the Best of NY by NY Daily News

Southern_Pecan_Pie

Little Pie Company's Pecan Pie is Rachael Ray's favorite mail order pie. Sarah Jessica Parker is also a big fan!

Dough_Half_Dozen

Bacon_Maple_Bar

Our beloved Dough & The Doughnut Project were both named The Absolute Best Doughnuts in NY by GrubStreet.

20101021-croissants-winnerinnards

(Photo Credit: Serious Eats)



These buttery croissants from Ceci Cela were voted Best Croissant in New York City by SeriousEats.com

So what are you waiting for?

Eat Cookies and Stay Fit!

There’s no one more excited for summer than this guy:

summer_blog

This is Stephen. You may not know him (yet), but here are some things that you need to know about him:

  • He loves summer
  • His biggest role model is Madonna
  • He is a fitness instructor in one of the city’s top gyms
  • He’s got an incredible mustache
  • He’s got an incredible fit body
  • He eats LOTS of baked goods.
  • And he still get an incredible fit body


  • It may sound a little suspicious, but it’s all true!
    That is because he’s also the founder of The Protein Bakery, one of the healthiest bakeries in NY, according to Well and Good. All their cookies, brownies and blondies are gluten-free (made with mainly oat flour) and enriched with whey protein. Their recipes have only natural ingredients, they are trans-fat free, gluten-free, and preservative-free, wheat flour-free, and fiber-rich but still taste like cookies and brownies, and not like...well, paper.

    proteinbakery1

    Perfect for those who are fitness fanatics but love a sweet snack and the ones that are trying to get there!

    If now that you got to know a little more about Stephen, you really feel like having a nice chat with him about Madonna or mustaches, you can stop at The Protein Bakery’s shop, West 19th St, Chelsea, NY. Or, if you just feel like ordering their delicious healthy goods, head to the Sweetist website and let us deliver to you! :)

    proteinbakery

    Here’s a picture of Stephen, his incredible mustache, and a nice lady <3

    The Protein Bakery: 144 W 19th St, New York, NY 10011

    5 Pies to Celebrate National Pi Day with in NYC

    Happy National Pi(e) Day! Sweetist is here to help you celebrate with some of the best pies in New York City. So without further ado, here’s our list of the best pies for you to shove in your piehole this National Pi Day.


    1. Little Pie Company Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie

    While none of the pies from Little Pie Company disappoint, our favorite (and their bestseller) is the Sour Cream Apple Walnut, layers of thinly sliced apple all topped with a crunchy, crumbly brown sugar walnut streusel.

    And for the entire week of Pi Day, if you buy a large pie in store, you’ll get a free sugar cookie shaped like the Pi symbol. So what are you waiting for? Go check them out!

    (or if you’re too lazy to move, get one delivered here)

    Little Pie Company / @eatdrinknomad


    2. Four & Twenty Blackbirds Salted Caramel Apple Pie

    Four and Twenty Blackbirds offers up a twist on the classic apple pie with their Salted Caramel Apple Pie. This slice features an apple filling with a barely there touch of caramel, topped with a flaky crust studded with coarse salt. Make sure to ask for some of their homemade whipped cream on the side!

    Four & Twenty Blackbirds / @shinyamadaaa


    3. Petee’s Pie Company Almond Chess Pie

    If fruity pies aren’t your thing, Petee’s Pie Company has got you covered. While their cherry crumb and blueberry pies are fantastic, that’s not what you’re here for. No, you’re here for a slice of one of their chess pies, available in almond, chocolate, salty (!) chocolate, lemon poppyseed, and even sesame varieties. Our favorite is the Almond Chess Pie, with a crisp top of layered almonds that gives way to a gooey, buttery custard. Here’s a tip: order it black bottom and get a thin layer of dark chocolate ganache at the bottom.

    Petee’s Pie Company / @fiery309fashionista


    4. Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pies Key Lime Pie (obviously)

    Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pies takes it back to the basics with a key lime pie made from only five ingredients: fresh key lime, condensed milk, egg yolks, graham crackers, and butter. They don’t sell slices, so order a mini pie or bring some friends and split a whole one (or eat it by yourself, we won’t judge). When it gets warmer out, opt for a Swingle, a chocolate-dipped mini key lime pie served on a stick.

    Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie / @deargracie


    5. Butter & Scotch S’mores Pie

    Butter & Scotch’s S’mores Pie definitely lives up to its name. With its sticky scorched marshmallow, smooth chocolate custard, and graham cracker crust, it’s essentially just a giant s’more. Which isn’t a bad thing. If a slice isn’t enough, you can also order any slice of pie as a milkshake, blended with your choice of ice cream.

    Spare yourself the trek to Brooklyn and order one here.

    Butter & Scotch / @delicategodzilla

    5 Best Peanut Butter Desserts in NYC

    In honor of National Peanut Butter Lover’s Day and the beginning of National Peanut Butter Month, we’ve compiled a list of the best peanut butter desserts in New York City.

    1. Levain Bakery Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip

    With lines curling around the block, clearly everyone and their mother knows about Levain’s gooey fist-sized chocolate chip cookies. But did you know that they come in dark chocolate peanut butter, too? Nah didn’t think so.

    Brave the line or get one delivered right to your doorstep here.

    image

    Levain Bakery / @chow_chick


    2. Doughnut Plant Peanut Butter and Jelly Doughnut  

    With its oozing, tart black berry jam center, eating one of these will definitely leave you with some shirt stains. But honestly, we’d eat Doughnut Plant’s pillowy peanut-studded yeast doughnuts plain, so we’re not going to complain. There’s also a banana cream filled version for all you Elvis lovers out there.

    image

    Doughnut Plant / @mrsropersmusings


    3. Billy’s Bakery Peanut Butter Chocolate Pie

    Pure peanut butter fluff in a graham cracker crust with a peanut rim, topped with peanut butter cups and a chocolate drizzle. It doesn’t get better than this.

    Treat yourself to a slice (or five) for yourself here.

    image

    Billys Bakery / @Mike Chau


    4. Butter & Scotch Trifecta Pie

    Oh wait, it might! Brooklyn’s boozy Butter & Scotch Bakery kicks it up a notch with the addition of salted pretzel to their dark chocolate peanut butter pie, lovingly dubbed the ‘Trifecta.’

    Spare yourself the subway ride to Brooklyn and get a slice here.

    image

    Butter & Scotch / @sweetistco


    5. Peanut Butter & Co Peanut Butters

    Okay, so it’s not technically a dessert, but nothing’s really stopping you from eating an entire jar of any of Peanut Butter & Co’s flavored peanut butters with a spoon. Our personal favorite is the Bee’s Knees, a peanut butter blended with honey (!!!). With flavors from chile to cinnamon raisin, and a slew of other nut butters, there’s something for everyone.

    image

    Peanut Butter & Co / @ourcozy

    La Newyorkina: Best Paletas in NYC

    This month’s Dessert Spotlight features a new addition to Sweetist: La Newyorkina, the Mexican paleteria/ice creamery/all things Mexican dessert shop run by Fany Gerson, also head of the Dough donut empire. While La Newyorkina’s carts and its refreshing paletas have been a feature of New York City summers since 2010, its first brick-and-mortar location in West Village has only been open a few months.

    The shop features an expanded menu, including not only its famed paletas, but also other frozen desserts, like handmade nieves de garrafa or helados, and other Mexican confections. And with a portion of their profits going to Crea, an organization based in Mexico that helps women from low-income households create and run small businesses, La Newyorkina is truly redefining the term “guilt-free dessert.”

    Head over to La Newyorkina to try some of these frozen treats, or learn how to make your own with Fany’s upcoming book, Mexican Ice Cream: Beloved Recipes and Stories (preorder here).

    Our Picks:

    Nieves de Garrafa

     Nieves de Garrafa is a hand-paddled water-based sorbet that Gerson describes as “custard in its purest form” is handmade in store daily. Flavors rotate everyday, but our favorites are the mango (pictured below) and the queso fresco, a soft Mexican cheese.

    image

    La Newyorkina / @lycynthialy

    Horchata Ice Cream

    With flavors ranging from pumpkin seed brittle to corn, horchata might not be the most creative flavor on the menu, but does that really matter when it’s this good? La Newyorkina’s horchata is creamy, but not overly so, with bits of cinnamon and sugar providing some much needed grit (pictured below with scoops of the coco-choco, a fresh coconut cream with dark chocolate bits, and the Oaxacan chocolate).

    image

    La Newyorkina / @lanewyorkina

    Available for delivery in hand-packed pints here.

    Paletas (duh)

    While you can’t go wrong with any of La Newyorkina’s paletas, from either fruity or creamy, or even a blend of both, our favorites are the canela and cajeta, a Mexican cinnamon ice encasing an oozing cajeta, or goat caramel, filling and the equally gooey fresa con crema (are you sensing a theme yet?), a strawberry paleta with a condensed milk center (both pictured below).

    canela and cajeta

    image

    La Newyorkina / @lanewyorkina

    fresas con crema

    image

    La Newyorkina / @lanewyorkina

    Available for delivery in packs of 12 in fruity, creamy, fruity & creamy, and classic flavored selections here.

    Learn more about La Newyorkina out here!

    5 Ways to Treat Yo' Self This Valentine's Day

    image

    Valentine’s Day is stressful. We’re here to help.

    1. Take a breather

    Life is busy, but sometimes you’ve just got to take a moment and smell the roses (or some rose flavored macarons from Mille-feuille).

    image

    Mille-feuille Bakery Cafe / @eatinggirl


    2. Get creative!

    Make something. Don’t just smell those rose flavored macarons, bake your own in Mille-feuille’s macaron-making classes.

    image

    Mille-feuille Bakery Cafe / @daleborchiver


    3. Snuggle up.

    All you need is a fuzzy blanket and a warm drink. A sea salt chocolate chip cookie from Sweet Corner Bakeshop wouldn’t hurt either.

    image

     Sweet Corner Bakeshop / @sweetcornernyc


    4. Literally treat yo’ self.

    Be a little sweet on yourself. With $5 off your first order and a selection of cookies, cupcakes, and other desserts from New York’s best bakeries delivered right to your door, Sweetist has got you covered.

    image

    Magnolia Bakery / @magnoliabakery


    5. And finally, donut worry.

    Preferably with this toasted coconut donut from Dough. No one actually likes Valentine’s Day.

    image

    Dough / @michellecircle

    NYC's Best Valentine's Desserts

    Valentine's Day is just around the corner, whether it's the day to celebrate love or a single awareness day to you, delicious desserts are suitable in either of those situations! So let Sweetist help you make the day as sweet as can be with these wonderful desserts from our site!

    Declare your love with this "Be Mine" cake from Sugar Sketch Cake Shop. Order Here

    fullsizerender_6

    Nothing says I love you quite like making a decadent chocolate cake together. Try this deliciously fun DIY kit from Red Velvet NYC. Order Here

    fullsizerender_4

    What could be a better way to tell your friends that you love them than these intense dark chocolate caneles from Canele by Celine. Order Here

    The best 4 letters word! Order Here

    fullsizerender_2

    And, of course, how could we leave out Valentine's Cupcakes from Billy's Bakery! Order Here

    fullsizerender_1

    For those of you who would rather stay in and forget about the world for 24 hours. We highly recommend a pint of this decadent ice-cream made from coconut and 62% Valrhona chocolate from La Newyorkina. Order Here

    fullsizerender_5

    or a 4-pint pack of spiked ice-cream from Tipsy Scoop - how good does dark chocolate whiskey salted caramel sound? Order Here

    fullsizerender-2

    NYC's Best Holiday Desserts

    Just a few more days until the most wonderful time of the year - the holidays! We’re all excited for the holidays, especially the great treats! If you need a great dessert prepared for your Christmas feast, Sweetist is here! Either let our Gift Concierge help you with all your holiday gifting needs or order these delicious seasonal treats online without hassle!

    White Chocolate Mint Cupcake

    screen-shot-2016-12-14-at-9-53-12-pm

    Nothing says holiday time quite like candy canes. Enjoy this sweet treat, topped with crumbled peppermint!

    Stump de Noel

    screen-shot-2016-12-14-at-9-53-17-pm

    A spin on the classic Buche De Noel, we turn this cake on its side! Chocolate sponge cake with a malted vanilla buttercream filling and a dark chocolate frosting on the outside. Decorated with fondant mushrooms, and florals/decor depending on season.

    Yule Log Cake - 3 Layer 9 Inch

    screen-shot-2016-12-14-at-9-53-23-pm

    Celebrate a tradition with this Yule Log inspired cake! The Yule Log is a wood block specially selected for burning as Christmas tradition.

    8” Apple Pie

    screen-shot-2016-12-14-at-9-53-30-pm

    Be warm and cozy with friends and family as you eat this classic favorite. The pie stands out with its unique star cut outs!

    Ornament Mini Cupcakes

    screen-shot-2016-12-14-at-9-53-35-pm

    No better way to show your festive nature than with this ornament box! Each cupcake has an ornament topper and is ready to share with guests!

    Introducing Sweetist Gift Concierge

    If you're hunting for the perfect holiday gifts for your family, clients, co-workers, or friends, let Sweetist Gift Concierge help you!

    Select your gifts from our curated collection of seasonal products from holiday cupcakes to Christmas cookies to yule log from the best bakeries in NYC. We've got all kinds of gifts covered.

    red-velvet-nyc-holiday-cheer-gift-set

    mb_yule-log-cakes

    mb_cookies

    Save yourself from the hassle of reentering delivery and payment information, and fill everything out in one go in an easy-to-follow template, and let our gift concierge handle the rest. Think of our Gift Concierge as your personal assistant for the holidays!

    gc

    Also, the larger the order, the bigger the discount! Get 5% off $150, 10% off $300, and 15% off $500.

    How it works:

    capture

     
    1. Download the recipient form template. The form helps you easily fill in all the necessary information we will need to complete your order.
    2. Browse our holidays offerings and choose your gift items.
    3. Fill in the form.
    4. Upload the form.
    5. Our Gift Concierge will get back to you within 24 hours.
    6. Sit back, relax, and enjoy the holiday season as Sweetist helps your spread the holiday cheers!
      Still have questions? Please contact our Gift Concierge at concierge@sweetist.co or see the FAQs for more information.

    Thanksgiving Desserts Ideas

    Thanksgiving is right around the corner, and Sweetist is here to make it as great as it can be! Don’t worry about making desserts for your meal; instead, order a few of these fall favorites from our site and enjoy more quality time with loved ones!

    Double Crust Apple Pie

    Double Crust Apple Pie

    Traditional apple pie made with Golden Delicious and Granny Smith apples topped with a double crust. Note: Available from 19th Nov till 24th Nov.

    Black Bottom Pecan Pie

    Black Bottom Pecan

    Pumpkin IceBox Pie

    icebox

    Creamy Pumpkin cream cheese filling in a gingernap crust with candied pecans. Note: Available from 19th Nov till 24th Nov.

    Pecan Caramel Tart

    icebox

    The perfect option for chocolate lovers - A crunchy tart filled with Valrhona chocolate ganache with light caramel and pecans.

    Pumpkin Loaf with Vanilla Icing

    Pumpkin Bread Loaf with Vanilla Icing

    Not quite in the mood for pie? Enjoy mini slices of this delicious pumpkin loaf as a sweet treat after your meal.

    Harvest Apple Cupcake

    Harvest Apple Cupcake pack of 6

    Made with fresh apples, cranberries, raisins and pecans and topped with a caramel meringue buttercream.